Civil cases are almost always complicated and require experienced lawyers. This goes from the initial intake, through discovery, to trial and to post judgment wrangling. For instance, in Arizona, a passenger injured while in a taxi sued the taxi company for damages related to the injuries. A Maricopa County jury awarded the passenger $700,000. Not a bad verdict. The Taxi Company filed a “Motion for New Trial, to Alter or Amend the Judgment, and for Remittitur.” In short, “Your Honor, reduce this jury verdict”. In a minute entry, the court granted a remittitur, reducing the award and ordering the plaintiff to file a notice accepting the remittitur. The passenger rejected the court’s remittitur, and requested the court issue a signed order setting a new trial. The trial court issued a signed minute entry on December 17, 2015, and the passenger appealed on January 14, 2016.

The Court of Appeals confirmed that the plaintiff timely appealed. Ariz. R. Civ. P. 59(i) states that if a party rejects a remittitur, the order granting a new trial is effective from the date the trial court established for the party to provide notice of accepting or rejecting the remittitur. Noting that the deadline set by the trial court was November 25, 2015, the Court further explained that a party cannot appeal an unsigned minute entry granting or denying a motion for new trial. Thus, regardless of Rule 59(i)’s self-executing nature, the appeal was timely because the passenger filed the appeal within 30 days of the signed December 17 minute entry order, the only signed order resolving the motion for a new trial. This is important, because the 30 days in non-negotiable and missing an Appeal date is fatal.

We have a good track record of helping get relief from judgments. Call Bill Miller at 602.319.6899 if you would like to discuss this, RICO claims, fraud, business law or real estate related matters. Our office is located at 8170 N. 86th Place, Suite 208 Scottsdale, Arizona 85258.

We also handle, Breach of contract, Non-compete agreements, Non-disclosure agreements, Employee theft and embezzlement, Insurance purchases and enforcement of policy coverage, Negotiation and/or enforcement of commercial leases, Negligence and gross negligence resulting in losses, Intentional acts causing a company to suffer damages, Tortious interference with contractual relationships, Unjust enrichment, Real Estate fraud, Consumer fraud, Conversion/Theft, Intentional and/or negligent misrepresentation, Business torts and Real estate title and escrow.

Comments are closed.